Summary: Child victims of extreme physical violence, such as stabbings or shootings, are at significantly higher risk of developing PTSD as adults.
Source: University of Rochester
A study of young adults who were victims of violent injuries as children found significantly higher levels of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in this group than the general population.
The study—conducted by University of Rochester Medical Center (URMC) researchers—surveyed 24 respondents who were victims of gunshot, stab, or assault wounds as children between the years of 2011 and 2020. Of the participants, 15 suffered a gunshot wound, eight suffered a stab wound, and one was assaulted.
Respondents were primarily teenagers at the time of injury, with a median age of 16.6 years. An average of six years had passed from the initial injury to the time respondents were contacted for the study.
Ten (41.7%) of these respondents screened positive for probable PTSD, significantly higher than the 6.8% of the general population that is typically diagnosed with PTSD. Patients who screened positive reported at least three of the following five traits:
- Nightmares or intrusive thoughts;
- Avoiding thinking about or being in situations that remind them of the event(s);
- Constantly feeling on-guard, watchful, or startled;
- Feeling numbness or detachment to people, activities, or surroundings;
- Feeling guilt or blaming yourself or others for the event or problems from the event.
In addition, 46% of respondents reported substance abuse in the past 30 days (other than alcohol or prescription medications) compared to approximately 13% of the general population, while nearly 17% reported persistent symptoms related to their injury.
These lasting physical and mental effects emphasize the need for hospitals, community organizations, and social support networks to work together to help monitor these patients long-term, according to lead author Nicole A. Wilson, Ph.D., MD, assistant professor in the departments of Surgery, Pediatrics, and Biomedical Engineering at URMC.
“The big take-home message is that we need to be doing better at following people who have these types of injuries, whether from gunshots or other violent acts, and we need to be assisting them and offering resources,” she said.
During this study, which was published in the Journal of Pediatric Surgery, respondents were offered resources to help with the physical and mental effects of their injuries. Nearly 63% accepted this offer, indicating that there is a high demand for support among this population.
“With any patient, there’s a range of materials available to help, but sometimes we are limited as clinicians as we can only control what happens when they are in the hospital,” said Wilson.
Violence victims at UR Medicine Golisano Children’s Hospital (GCH) are referred to Pathways to Peace—a street-level team that provides support and nonviolent alternatives for youth who are resorting to violence to settle disputes or becoming involved in gangs and drugs—but many decline this option.
The main reason why patients decline this option is unclear, according to Wilson, but she speculates that families might find this option intrusive, or that long-term mistrust of the healthcare system from historically-marginalized communities prevents them from embracing partnerships offered by the hospital.
“I think it would be helpful if we had a broader range of interventions and resources we could offer, as certain families may prefer a different service or approach,” said Wilson. “Additional funding, research, and time will help us develop these options.”
There is an effort to significantly expand this initial research with a follow-up collaboration between GCH and several other Upstate and Western New York children’s hospitals. Wilson hopes this collaboration will produce a more robust respondent pool, with more control groups, and ultimately help these institutions secure long-term funding to continue to study this topic.
“Using this type of research at a larger scale, we can also look at the role of social determinants of health and socio-economic conditions, and we can also try to procure funding for additional interventions,” said Wilson.
In addition, GCH’s recent designation as a Level 1 Trauma Center has given the institution a mandate to engage in expanded community partnerships to address youth gun violence and educate other trauma centers.
Wilson believes that consistent availability of follow-up behavioral health resources could significantly help youth with the fallout effects of violence.
“In an ideal world, there would be a mechanism where they could automatically see a counselor in three months,” she said.
About this psychology research news
Original Research: Closed access.
“Long-term functional, psychological, emotional, and social outcomes in pediatric victims of violence” by Naomi S. Ganpo-Nkwenkwa et al. Journal of Pediatric Surgery
Long-term functional, psychological, emotional, and social outcomes in pediatric victims of violence
To evaluate the long-term functional, psychological, and emotional outcomes in individuals who survived violence-related injuries as children.
We retrospectively identified all pediatric patients (age <18y at time of injury) treated for a violent traumatic injury (gun-shot wound, stab, or assault) at our institution (1/2011–12/2020). We then prospectively attempted to contact and survey, via telephone, all patients that had reached adulthood (age ≥18y at time of study) using 7 Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS) instruments and the Primary Care Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) screen.
Of the 270 patients identified, we attempted to contact 218, successfully contacted 68, and 24 participated in the study. Of participants, 15 (62.5%) sustained gunshot wounds, 8 (33.3%) were stabbed, and 1 (4.2%) was assaulted with a median time from injury of 6.7(3.4) years. Based on PROMIS metrics, Global Physical Health (55.0 vs. 50.0, p = 0.013) and Emotional Support (55.4 vs. 50.0, p = 0.004) were better in participants compared to reference populations. However, a disproportionate number of participants reported substance use in the past 30 days (45.8 vs 13.0%; p < 0.001), 41.7% screened positive for PTSD, and 62.5% requested resources and/or referral for medical care.
Many individuals who survive violent injuries as children continued to experience negative physical and mental outcomes extending into adulthood that required ongoing medical and psychological support. Further resources are needed to better understand the long-term effects of violent injury and to care for the complex needs of this population.